Erik
Photosource: CBS

What the heck was Erik thinking?  Why on the face of the this entire water and land filled earth would you give up your special priceless immunity idol against four female competitors?  Okay, okay, okay...we can give him credit on ... no we can't.  That was the biggest mess up, the most magnificent set up in Survivor history.  Gotta feel sorry for him on this one because it was simply too huge.  If you didn't see this episode, watch it.

See more of Survivor and Erik, the man who made the worst mistake on Survivor here.